Best Crib Mattress – Guide & Reviews

We don’t give it a much of thought, but Buying Best Crib Mattress for Baby is actually more serious than it looks! We need to look into various factors and issues before we jump into conclusion.

Sometimes we need to look at reputed brands, go through a lot of crib mattress reviews online and even look at consumer experiences. Striking the right balance between safety and comfort is important.

I believe this detailed guide will help you immensely in your research. Here I’ve listed few of the crucial aspects you need to keep in mind while choosing a suitable mattress.

And just to get you going, I’ve listed down 5 Best Crib Mattress Recommendations as well.

What is a Crib Mattress?

Crib mattresses are just like mattresses we put on our beds. Except, they are much smaller. Crib mattresses are small pieces of foam that go into the crib of your baby.

They are designed to provide some much-needed comfort and cushioning to your child when he/she sleeps.

These crib mattresses can be of various types starting from memory foam, normal foam, polyurethane and more. When buying these things, you need to look into few things along with their types to ensure your kid gets the most out of it.

How to Select the Best Crib Mattress for Your Baby

To sum it up in one sentence, this is a tricky job but the fact is, looking into few factors can make your purchase a good bargain.

I’ve listed down few things that you have to look at while getting your baby the Best Crib Mattress available.

Choose the right type of mattress for kids. It is important as there are many types of mattresses available these days. For example, there are foam mattresses, innerspring mattresses, and organic ones.

Choose the one you think is good enough. Each one has its own benefits and drawbacks.

Purchase a breathable crib mattress with just the right firmness and of course, the right size. Breathable mattresses allow your children to breath while they lie face down on the crib.

Also, the right amount of firmness is necessary. You can’t expect a crib mattress to be too firm on your kid or sag prematurely.

Buy a resilient mattress. It is important to choose one that regains its shape after you push it down in the middle. The faster it regains the shape, the better.

Best Crib Mattress for me is the one with water resistant cover. A good cover makes half the job easier for parents. You don’t have to worry about internal damages and can clean the stuff easily. I’d buy a machine washable cover for myself.

Safety for your infant/toddler is necessary. You’d want a mattress that is safe and has a track record of durability. For that, nothing beats certifications from top institutes of the USA.

These guys know what they’re doing when certifying the mattresses. I’d look for some certifications in safety standards before jumping on to buying some of the mattresses if I were you.

Ventilation is always a crucial thing to look at. You need to buy a mattress which has tiny holes to circulate the air. It keeps the bed usable for a longer period.

Recommended : Best Crib Mattress

If you guys are having troubles while choosing the ideal crib mattres , I’ve got the perfect shortlist of Best Crib Mattres in the section below. Please have a look.

Editor Rating:

The first thing you buy, maybe even before your baby is born is a crib – possibly the best one available. And only the best crib mattress can accompany it.

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is a promising name in this regard.

Heavenly Dreams is suitable for your baby in every way.

It is hypoallergenic. And it is free of phthalates and lead-free. Safety 1st has got GREENGUARD GOLD Certification. This imported crib mattress is lightweight and extremely durable.

One will probably last till your baby stops needing a crib. Moreover, its vinyl cover is water-resistant and is easy to clean.

Lastly, your baby will spend cozy-comfortable hours with it due to the high density thermo-bonded fiber core.


  • It is hypoallergenic and waterproof.
  • Affordable and lightweight.
  • You can clean it easily.
  • Phthalate free.


  • The mattress can be noisy.
  • It is not particularly breathable.
  • Not a dual sided mattress

Editor Rating:

A great crib is lonely without a great mattress. And if you are looking for one, check out the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress.

It is a product of advanced technology used in mattress making.

Instead of crude oil, natural soybean oil, produced by American farmers, are used in its manufacture.

Soybean oil is a renewable resource, and it makes manufacturing hypoallergenic and firm foam an eco-friendly job. This feature alone can mark Sealy as the best crib mattress.

This high-density crib mattress is GREENGUARD GOLD Certified and has reduced chances of sagging.

It is designed with a pearl embossed cover and lock-stitched binding, which altogether makes it waterproof and stain-resistant.You can easily clean it using mild soap and water or just baby wipe.

Instead of metal rings, airflow pocket is designed to allow air circulation. It is suitable for infants and toddlers, so you can use it for a long time.


  • It is made from safe, environment-friendly material.
  • Recommended by American Academy of Pediatrics for baby’s comfort.
  • It resists stains and it waterproof.
  • You can clean it easily with a damp cloth.
  • The corners are nicely “Square-cut” to fit into any crib.


  • Few reviewers mentioned, this mattress sags after some time.
  • This might be a little too firm for the newborns.

Editor Rating:

Nothing is more caring than nature. And if your baby’s crib mattress is also a product of nature, there can be hardly anything better than that.

The Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer is manufactured using plant oil infused foam material.

It is GREENGUARD GOLD Certified, and it is free of polyethylene, PVC, phthalates, and lead. So, don’t worry about endangering your child with chemicals.

It is hypoallergenic from both outside and inside. The waterproof vinyl cover is stain-resistant and is a flexible medical grade stretch knit fabric.

The Little Dreamer is made to provide a safe haven to your infant angel. It is treated with ultra-fresh to make it antimicrobial. Moonlight crib mattresses are extra firm, which is optimum for every growing child.


  • There are two sides to this mattress.
  • Suitable for both your infant and toddlers.
  • Lightweight mattress, easy to move around.
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty.
  • Free from chemicals that can cause skin problems.


  • The mattress comes with a nylon cover that’s too thin.
  • Due to the odor, the mattress needs to be dried for 72 hours before placing it in a crib.

Editor Rating:

As much as you would like your beloved newborn to have all the best of things, it is not very easy to find them.

But here, we can make your endeavor a little easier. The My First Crib Mattress is surely one of the best crib mattresses you can find on the market.

It meets all your standards and thus provides your infant with utmost comfort. The flexible polyurethane foam used in its manufacture is CertiPUR-US Certified. This means it is hypoallergenic, lead and phthalate free, mite-proof and antimicrobial.

The foam is extra firm and has high density, yet it can give your baby comfortable sleeping hours along with support.

Moreover, the removable cover is washable and waterproof. Plus, the cover is subtle to your infant’s skin, providing a homely feeling.


  • The memory foam is firm enough to comfort your child.
  • Comes with a removable and machine washable cover.
  • You can get 10-year warranty with this mattress.
  • Changing covers and moving this thing around is fairly easy.


  • It is focused on “Infants” only.
  • Doesn’t have a softer side.
  • Stitches start to come off after frequent using.
  • Too firm for babies according to some parents.

Editor Rating:

Most of the time, all mattresses don’t fit all cribs, and that is bothersome.

But there is one crib mattress, possibly one of the bests, which fits all American standard sized cribs.

It is the Colgate Eco Classica III Crib Mattress.

It might be because, this crib mattress is manufactured in the USA, so it knows what the people need.

Colgate is GREENGUARD GOLD certified, thus has no risks of harmful emissions. Plus, it is CertiPUR-US certified safe. Thus it’s named Eco Classica.

It is made with memory foam – foam that meets all needs. It is provided with a waterproof, eco-friendly cover, which is PVC free and medical grade.

Colgate Classica III is 6” thick and has dual firmness. This allows you to use this crib mattress starting from your baby’s infant days to their toddler years.


  • Colgate Eco Classica is an eco-friendly mattress.
  • Cleaning this crib mattress is as easy as pie.
  • Odorless mattress; ideal for kids.
  • This is a lightweight, dual sided mattress


  • Has rounded edges.
  • Stains are tough to omit after a few days.


I've also prepared lists of other baby product reviews that you might find useful. 

Final Verdict

As I keep saying, buying the crib mattress is a hard choice to make. There are many options available both online and in the physical stores.

The best thing for you would be to go through the baby crib mattress reviews and the short buying guide I provided earlier.

These instructions and short reviews will point you towards the right direction when it comes to selecting the best crib mattress for your kid.

Evelyne F. Ford

Product reviewer & passionate blogger. Besides writing for this blog, I spend my time crafting research based contents for HuffingtonPost, Lifehacker & Forbes!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments